Skip to content

Rorschach Test Scandal on Wikipedia and the Aftermath

The Rorschach test is used for examining the personality characteristics and emotional functioning of patients as their perceptions of inkblots are recorded and then analyzed. In 2009, the New York Times had a report about Dr. James Heilman who posted all 10 pictures on the site, along with research about the most popular responses to each. Of course, it led to a heated debate whether this information should be accessed on Wikipedia or not. Here are the details of this scandal.

ror1

Now, 2 years later, a study came out with the title “Challenges since wikipedia: the availability of rorschach information online and internet users’ reactions to online media coverage of the rorschach-wikipedia debate.“. The abstract:

In the first study, the authors conducted 2 Google searches for Web sites containing Rorschach-related information. The top 88 results were classified by level of threat to test security; 19% posed a direct threat. The authors also found Web sites authored by psychologists that divulged sensitive Rorschach information.

In the second study, 588 comments to online news stories covering the Rorschach-Wikipedia debate were coded as expressing favorable or unfavorable opinions regarding the field of psychology, psychologists, and the Rorschach. Eight percent of comments described unfavorable opinions toward psychology, 15% contained unfavorable opinions toward psychologists, and 35% portrayed unfavorable opinions of the Rorschach.

Common themes and popular misconceptions of the Rorschach contained in these comments are described. Implications and recommendations for practice are discussed. Limitations, including the second study’s narrow sample and self-selection bias, are also detailed.

 

 

About these ads
2 Comments Post a comment
  1. Anonymous #

    I was pressured into seeing a psychiatrist in 2007 after being honorably discharged from active duty in the Navy. They used this test and some other test consisting of black and white photos to determine that I have a personality disorder. The military still uses it against me to determine my fitness for duty. It has been eight years now, and to be honest this has caused a lot of harm to me as a person.

    After careful research and study, I am saddened at how they can label you with whatever they want just from using pictures and questionnaires.Also, because they are physicians and they have the authority to sign someone’s life off, they can “override” anything they want. Then they claim they are here to help you, but your life falls apart. It is an ungodly and unethical industry. I pray that no one falls for this trap….

    August 16, 2014
  2. Anonymous #

    I was pressured into seeing a psychiatrist in 2007 after being honorably discharged from active duty in the Navy. They used this test and some other test consisting of black and white photos to determine that I have a personality disorder. The military still uses it against me to determine my fitness for duty. It has been eight years now, and to be honest this has caused a lot of harm to me as a person.

    After careful research and study, I am saddened at how they can label you with whatever they want just from using pictures and questionnaires. Also, because they are physicians they have the authority to sign someone’s life off, and they can “override” anything they want. Then they claim they are here to help you, but your life falls apart. They can label anyone who walks into their clinics with these humiliating diagnoses and then hand them drugs with humiliating names. It is an ungodly and unethical industry of death. I pray that no one falls for this trap….

    August 16, 2014

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 41,697 other followers

%d bloggers like this: